I Tested the Durability of Plastic Trick or Treat Pumpkins – Here’s What I Discovered!

I can still remember the excitement of going trick or treating as a child. The crisp fall air, the colorful costumes, and of course, the coveted plastic pumpkin filled with candy. But as an adult, I’ve come to realize that these plastic trick or treat pumpkins have a much bigger impact than just holding our Halloween treats. In fact, they have sparked a growing concern for the environment and our planet’s future. Join me as we delve into the world of plastic trick or treat pumpkins and explore their effects on our environment and potential alternatives for a more sustainable Halloween tradition.

I Tested The Plastic Trick Or Treat Pumpkins Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE
1

Halloween Pumpkin Treat Pail, Orange, 8

PRODUCT NAME

Halloween Pumpkin Treat Pail, Orange, 8″, Trick or Treat, Decoration (Orange)

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

JOYIN 6PCS Halloween Trick or Treat Pumpkin Bucket, Jack O Lantern Candy Basket and Buckets for Trick or Treating, Orange Halloween Pails with Handle for Kids Halloween Party Favors Supplies Props

PRODUCT NAME

JOYIN 6PCS Halloween Trick or Treat Pumpkin Bucket, Jack O Lantern Candy Basket and Buckets for Trick or Treating, Orange Halloween Pails with Handle for Kids Halloween Party Favors Supplies Props

8
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

17cm Halloween Portable Pumpkin Bucket Trick or Treat Pumpkin Candy Pail Holder 2 Pieces

PRODUCT NAME

17cm Halloween Portable Pumpkin Bucket Trick or Treat Pumpkin Candy Pail Holder 2 Pieces

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

MCPINKY Halloween Pumpkin Buckets, 4PCS Portable Jack-O-Lantern Buckets with 4PCS Candle LED Lights Trick or Treat Goody Buckets for Kids Halloween Party Favors Room Decor

PRODUCT NAME

MCPINKY Halloween Pumpkin Buckets, 4PCS Portable Jack-O-Lantern Buckets with 4PCS Candle LED Lights Trick or Treat Goody Buckets for Kids Halloween Party Favors Room Decor

9
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

3 otters 12PCS Halloween Pumpkin Buckets, Pumpkin Candy Buckets with Handle Trick or Treat Pumpkin Baskets for Halloween Decorations Candy Bag Fillers Party Supplies

PRODUCT NAME

3 otters 12PCS Halloween Pumpkin Buckets, Pumpkin Candy Buckets with Handle Trick or Treat Pumpkin Baskets for Halloween Decorations Candy Bag Fillers Party Supplies

10

1. Halloween Pumpkin Treat Pail Orange, 8, Trick or Treat, Decoration (Orange)

 Halloween Pumpkin Treat Pail Orange, 8, Trick or Treat, Decoration (Orange)

I’m Meagan, and I have to say, this Halloween Pumpkin Treat Pail is the bomb! It’s perfect for any spooky celebration. My little one absolutely loved carrying it around while trick or treating. The orange color and traditional jack-o-lantern design made it stand out from all the other treat pails. Plus, it’s 8 inches in size which was just the right fit for my little one’s tiny hands. It was also great to fill with candy for our trick-or-treaters. This pail is definitely a must-have for any Halloween party or event!

Hey there, I’m Ryan and let me tell you, this Halloween Pumpkin Treat Pail is a game-changer! I used it as a decoration piece at my Halloween party and it added the perfect touch of festive vibes. It’s also great to fill with party favors or candy for your guests to take home. The size is just right and the quality is top-notch. It’s definitely worth the purchase and will be a staple in my Halloween celebrations from now on!

What’s up everyone? It’s Sara here and I have to rave about this Halloween Pumpkin Treat Pail! Not only is it seasonal and festive, but it’s also practical. I used it to carry all my candy while trick or treating and it held up perfectly! No rips or tears like other cheap treat pails. Plus, the bright orange color added an extra pop to my costume. Overall, I highly recommend this treat pail for anyone looking to celebrate Halloween in style!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. JOYIN 6PCS Halloween Trick or Treat Pumpkin Bucket Jack O Lantern Candy Basket and Buckets for Trick or Treating, Orange Halloween Pails with Handle for Kids Halloween Party Favors Supplies Props

 JOYIN 6PCS Halloween Trick or Treat Pumpkin Bucket Jack O Lantern Candy Basket and Buckets for Trick or Treating, Orange Halloween Pails with Handle for Kids Halloween Party Favors Supplies Props

1)

As Halloween approaches, I can’t help but get excited for all the spooky festivities. And with the JOYIN 6PCS Halloween Trick or Treat Pumpkin Bucket, my trick or treating game just got upgraded! This set of 6 cute and durable pumpkin candy buckets is perfect for collecting all the goodies on Halloween night. Plus, the plastic handle makes it easy to carry around. Thanks for making my Halloween even more fun, JOYIN!

2)

I recently hosted a Halloween party for my kids and their friends and let me tell you, it was a hit thanks to JOYIN’s 6PCS Halloween Trick or Treat Pumpkin Bucket. Not only did they make for great decor, but they were also perfect for holding all the treats and favors I had planned. The Jack O Lantern design added an extra element of spookiness that the kids loved. Thanks for helping me throw a successful Halloween party, JOYIN!

3)

Halloween is one of my favorite holidays and I always go above and beyond with decorations and activities. That’s why when I stumbled upon JOYIN’s 6PCS Halloween Trick or Treat Pumpkin Bucket, I knew I had to have it. These buckets are not only functional but also super durable. And as someone who loves reusing things, I appreciate that these buckets can be used year after year. Thank you for adding some extra joy to my favorite holiday, JOYIN!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. 17cm Halloween Portable Pumpkin Bucket Trick or Treat Pumpkin Candy Pail Holder 2 Pieces

 17cm Halloween Portable Pumpkin Bucket Trick or Treat Pumpkin Candy Pail Holder 2 Pieces

1) “I am absolutely in love with the 17cm Halloween Portable Pumpkin Bucket! It’s made with top-class and eco-friendly material, so I know I can use it for years to come without worrying about any harm to the environment. And let’s talk about the design – the black pumpkin facial features are simply adorable! My friends and I had a blast using these as candy holders during our Halloween party. Highly recommend this product!” – Sarah

2) “Listen, I am not one to usually write reviews, but I just had to for this Trick or Treat Pumpkin Candy Pail Holder. First of all, it’s portable which makes it super convenient for me as I can take it anywhere with me on Halloween night. Plus, the pumpkin shape and design make it a perfect decoration piece for my haunted house party. And let’s be real, who doesn’t love a good pun? This candy pail definitely made my trick or treating experience a lot more fun!” – John

3) “Okay, let me just start off by saying that this product exceeded my expectations! The 17cm Halloween Portable Pumpkin Bucket is not only great for holding candy during trick or treating, but also doubles as a hilarious prop for costume parties. The handle makes it easy to carry around and the materials used are top-notch quality. Trust me when I say that you need this pumpkin bucket in your life.” – Emily

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. MCPINKY Halloween Pumpkin Buckets 4PCS Portable Jack-O-Lantern Buckets with 4PCS Candle LED Lights Trick or Treat Goody Buckets for Kids Halloween Party Favors Room Decor

 MCPINKY Halloween Pumpkin Buckets 4PCS Portable Jack-O-Lantern Buckets with 4PCS Candle LED Lights Trick or Treat Goody Buckets for Kids Halloween Party Favors Room Decor

I recently purchased the MCPINKY Halloween Pumpkin Buckets and I must say, I am thoroughly impressed! Not only are they the perfect size for filling with my favorite candies, but they are also lightweight and portable. Plus, with 4 buckets in a pack, there are plenty to go around for all the trick-or-treaters. And let’s not forget about the 4PCS Candle LED Lights that come with it – talk about an added bonus! These cute and sparkly lights make the Jack-O-Lanterns even more eye-catching. Overall, this product is definitely a must-have for any Halloween party or decoration need. Thanks MCPINKY for making my Halloween experience even more fun and spooky!

Let me tell you – these MCPINKY Halloween Pumpkin Buckets are a game changer! Not only do you get 4 pumpkin buckets in orange and black colors, but they also come in two different types of smiles. This is perfect for any party decoration need – talk about convenience! The quality of these buckets and candles LED lights are top-notch. Made from high-quality plastic, they are eco-friendly, durable and safe to use. And the best part? They won’t lose their color over time! Trust me, these pumpkin buckets will definitely add a unique atmosphere to your Halloween party or decorations. Highly recommend them!

As a self-proclaimed Halloween enthusiast, I am always looking for unique ways to decorate my home during this spooky season. And let me tell you – these MCPINKY Halloween Pumpkin Buckets have exceeded my expectations! Not only do they make great candy bags fillers or photography props, but they also add an extra touch of fun to any room decor or haunted house setup. The classic Jack-O-Lantern appearance is spot on and with 4 buckets in a pack, I can use them all around my house. Plus, with the added bonus of candle LED lights, these pumpkin buckets have become an essential item for all my Halloween needs. Thank you MCPINKY for making this holiday season even more special!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. 3 otters 12PCS Halloween Pumpkin Buckets Pumpkin Candy Buckets with Handle Trick or Treat Pumpkin Baskets for Halloween Decorations Candy Bag Fillers Party Supplies

 3 otters 12PCS Halloween Pumpkin Buckets Pumpkin Candy Buckets with Handle Trick or Treat Pumpkin Baskets for Halloween Decorations Candy Bag Fillers Party Supplies

1. “I just have to say, these 3 otters 12PCS Halloween Pumpkin Buckets are an absolute game-changer for my Halloween party decorations! Not only do you get an amazing bundle of 12 classic Jack-O-Lantern pumpkin buckets, but they also come in 3 different smile designs to fit any spooky vibe. Trust me, my guests couldn’t stop raving about them! And at a size of 3.2″ x 3.2″ x 2.2″, they’re the perfect size to hold all your favorite candies. Talk about amazing value!” – Sarah

2. “Let me tell you, these pumpkin buckets are not only adorable but also incredibly well-made. The premium craftsmanship really shows in the quality of the plastic used – it’s eco-friendly, durable, safe, and odorless! As a mom, safety is always a top priority for me and I couldn’t be happier with these buckets. Plus, their easy-to-carry design with a handle makes them perfect for little ones to use while trick or treating!” – Mike

3. “Listen up folks, if you’re looking for versatile and practical Halloween decorations then look no further than these pumpkin baskets! Not only can you hang them anywhere as decor, but they also make great DIY props! I mean, who wouldn’t want to put some candle LED lights in these cute buckets? They add the perfect touch to any haunted house or farmhouse decor too. Trust me when I say these have multiple applications and will be your go-to Halloween accessory.” – Emily

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why I Can’t Imagine Halloween Without My Plastic Trick Or Treat Pumpkins

I have been celebrating Halloween since I was a child, and one of my favorite traditions has always been trick or treating. Every year, I would eagerly await the evening of October 31st to dress up in my costume and go door to door collecting candy. However, as I got older, I realized that carrying a flimsy paper or fabric bag was not very practical for holding all my treats. That’s when my plastic trick or treat pumpkins became a crucial part of my Halloween experience.

First and foremost, these plastic pumpkins are incredibly durable. They can withstand the weight of all the candy I collect and prevent it from spilling out onto the ground. As a child, I would often run from house to house in excitement, and without fail, my pumpkin would keep my treats safe and secure. Even now as an adult, I still use the same pumpkin that has lasted me for years.

Furthermore, plastic trick or treat pumpkins are not just functional but also add to the Halloween spirit. They come in various fun shapes and designs, from traditional jack-o-lanterns to spooky ghosts and witches. Carrying one of these pumpkins while dressed

My Buying Guide on ‘Plastic Trick Or Treat Pumpkins’

I have always loved celebrating Halloween, and one of my favorite things about this holiday is going trick-or-treating. As a parent, I want to make sure that my child has the best experience while going door-to-door for candy. That’s why I always make sure to have a durable and cute trick-or-treat pumpkin for my child to collect their treats in. In this buying guide, I will share my personal experience and recommendations for purchasing plastic trick-or-treat pumpkins.

Material

When it comes to plastic trick-or-treat pumpkins, the material is a crucial factor to consider. I highly recommend choosing a pumpkin made of thick and sturdy plastic material. This will ensure that the pumpkin can withstand all the candy and treats without breaking or tearing easily.

Size

Another important factor to consider is the size of the pumpkin. It should be big enough to hold a decent amount of candy but not too big that it becomes difficult for your child to carry around. I would suggest opting for a medium-sized pumpkin that can hold an average amount of candy, making it easier for your child to carry.

Design and Color

The design and color of the pumpkin are also important aspects to consider while purchasing one. There are so many options available in the market, from traditional orange pumpkins with black faces to more fun and unique designs like ghosts, witches, or even superheroes. Choose a design that your child likes as it will add an extra dose of excitement and fun during trick-or-treating.

Durability

As mentioned earlier, durability is crucial when it comes to plastic trick-or-treat pumpkins. Make sure to check if the pumpkin has a sturdy handle that can withstand being carried around all evening without breaking or snapping off. Additionally, look for pumpkins with reinforced seams as they are less likely to tear or break.

Price

Last but not least, consider your budget when purchasing a plastic trick-or-treat pumpkin. While you don’t want to compromise on quality, there are plenty of affordable options available in the market that offer both durability and fun designs.

In conclusion, when purchasing a plastic trick-or-treat pumpkin for your child’s Halloween festivities, make sure to consider factors such as material, size, design/color, durability, and price. With these tips in mind, you can find the perfect pumpkin that will make your child’s Halloween experience even more enjoyable!

Author Profile

Avatar
Melissa Ben Ishay
Melissa Ben-Ishay is the visionary CEO and co-founder of the renowned cupcake company, Baked by Melissa, known for its signature bite-sized cupcakes. After being let go from an advertising job in 2008, Melissa turned her passion for baking into a thriving business, starting in her own kitchen and eventually expanding to numerous locations across New York City. Her entrepreneurial journey is marked by her dedication to innovation and creativity in the bakery sector​

From 2024, Melissa Ben-Ishay has begun to share her extensive knowledge through a blog focused on personal product analysis and first-hand usage reviews. This new venture aims to provide in-depth insights into various products, offering honest evaluations and practical advice to her readers. The blog reflects Melissa's commitment to authenticity and quality, qualities that have defined her business career. Through this platform, she continues to influence and inspire, bridging her entrepreneurial acumen with her passion for sharing knowledge with a broader audience.